Unschooling and Halloween

Sue Patterson

A few topics come up each year as we approach the "holiday" season. Like what?

  • Candy consumption
  • Big Kids trick-or-treating
  • Critics & Judgement


And at the bottom of this post:

  • A list of spooky movies that are kid-friendly
  • Halloween Memes
  • Pinterest Links for fun activities


With Halloween around the corner, if you’re on any of the Unschooling Mom2Mom social media platforms (Instagram, Facebook, Pinterest), you’ve seen a few memes! We really get into holidays! And Halloween is no exception! 


But with this particular holiday, parents bump into some tough decisions.

So that’s what I want to talk with you about in this last week of October. 

Things like Candy Consumption, whether to let Big Kids Trick or Treat, and what to do with the Critics in our lives - those people who don’t like the decisions we’re making. 


Candy Consumption


So let’s start with all that candy. Yes, lots of people give out other things besides candy - and you may do this too. But if your kids trick-or-treat, they’ll be coming home with a whole lot of sugary loot!
Realistically, even if you don’t do Halloween, we’re entering The Candy Season. So this candy issue starts at Halloween and then continues on through the end of the year right? The Holidays are full of sweet treats! 


In general, most parents have been learning more about nutrition and there are some pitfalls that can come with our sugary obsession. 

That being said, candy and sweet desserts are woven into our holiday experiences.

So...what's a conscientious mom to do?


Everyone is going to handle this differently, but there are a couple of points I want to remind you about the concept of



Forbidden Fruit - When we're told we can't have something, it makes us want it more, right?
So if you fall into the camp of wanting to dole out the candy a little at a time, you’re going to elevate it’s importance to the kids. This often leads to kids sneaking to get more or lying about how much they’ve had. But when we parcel it out - making it the forbidden fruit - we’ve created that dynamic. 


Lots of parents think,

"Oh! But if I don’t put some limits on them, they’ll eat it all and make themselves sick.”

And if you HAVE been limiting it, that may well happen. But they’ll learn from that tummy ache.
And you’ll have the opportunity to talk with them about what’s going on. Remember, it’s about partnering with them - even on topics like candy.


I do remember talking to a grown unschooler who was a new mom. She had grown up with this concept.
So when she left the candy on the coffee table, her toddler was devouring it all. But, it’s ok, especially for little ones, to put the bag or bowl of candy out of their line of sight. They WILL learn to manage it, but toddlers aren’t really there yet. Enjoy the candy
with them - sprinkle in other food they like.


You could even do what she did and create their own fruit roll-up style of “candy” from dehydrated fruit. The child didn’t really see the difference between that and the other candy. And the interaction between mom and child stayed positive.


Many Unschooling moms, over the years, have shared how their kids pick through what they like first, then didn’'t seem to be as interested in it later on. It takes a little bit of trust on your part though. But time and time again, we see kids learn how to manage this freedom.

At our house, we kept this black plastic "cauldron" near our front door full of the candy that had been collected at Halloween. Year after year, I'd have to dump it at the end of the following summer to get ready for the NEW candy that would be coming in. For a while, we lived on an Air Force Base, and with three kids, they had quite a haul! Interestingly, the kids who had their candy rationed out or removed entirely - they were the ones who dove into that cauldron whenever they came over. My kids kind of shrugged it off.


🗣 Follow the conversation over the Unschooling Mom2Mom Facebook Group - here
🍬 Read real-life examples of unschoolers who have dealt with candy consumption from an unschooling perspective:
True Tales of Kids Turning Down Sweets



Cavities - Lots of parents are worried about the damage sugar can do to teeth. But research shows that your DNA - whether you have strong healthy teeth - has a lot more to do with whether or not you'll get cavities. Kids who have a tendency for cavities will probably get them even if you skipped the Halloween candy altogether.

Parents in the FB group shared ideas for how to approach this:

  • Rinsing with water after eating
  • Eat foods that are "natural teeth cleaners" like celery, apples, hard cheeses
  • Offer xylitol gum after eating candy (apparently bacteria doesn't like to grow around xylitol)
  • Bringing kid flossers to them while they're watching YouTube or playing something while sitting still
  • Brushing teeth before bed so it's not sitting there all night
  • From a dental care standpoint, getting molars sealed and finding a dentist who works quickly with problem teeth


🍎 Interesting study:  Tooth Decay Bacteria Evolved as Diet Changed


Practical Tips:


Make sure the kids are full before they go trick or treating. We used to host a little potluck with macaroni and hot dogs as our the kids’ friends assembled before hitting the neighborhood. Other moms I know have had pizza. My friend and nutritionist, Karen Kennedy advised us all to have a BIG lunch and then a protein-packed smaller dinner. 

This is the nutrition-smart way to offset the sugar that’s coming to their systems.



Eat a big lunch and some protein for dinner.
Instead of fighting the candy, be smart.

Have a big, healthy lunch for Halloween day.
Then have a small, early dinner with plenty of protein...
something like turkey sandwiches, scrambled eggs or a lentil soup.

Yeah, they'll have more candy than you'd like. 🍬
But it won't cause as much trouble if they leave with some protein in their belly.
Have fun!! 👻👻👻

From Karen Kennedy @karenkennedynutrition
Certified Nutritionist at Real Food Matters
Karen also shares some tips if you're planning the food in
Healthier Parties for Children

________________

"We make sure everyone eats a couple slices of pizza before we head out trick-or-treating."
FB Group member/mom

________________

"We invited kids over to get ready at our house - while we served a potluck dinner full of kid-friendly foods! Nothing like filling up their tummy BEFORE the big adventure!"  ~Sue Patterson



When we can stop being so fearful about candy, we can plan ahead and then also prioritize the connection.
The stress and the tension will decrease.

Big Kids Trick-or-Treating


Lots of people feel like the big kids need to leave it with the littles. But I think that’s an anti-teen sentiment that’s really prevalent in society. Sure, they want free candy.


On one hand, we complain that kids grow up too quickly.
Then, we tell them they're too big for trick-or-treating!


Let’s look at what else is maybe going on:

Think of these things:

  • They want to enjoy a holiday that has special memories for them
  • It's an opportunity to have fun with their friends in a safe way
  • Maybe they love having the chance to dress up and "play make-believe" (even though they've "outgrown" it!)
  • They're part of your community too!


Don't be afraid of bigger kids!


Also Remember this...

A Child taking more than one piece of candy may have fine motor needs.

A Child taking a while to choose their candy may have motor planning or processing needs.

A Child who doesn't say, "Trick or Treat" or "Thank you" may have communication needs.

A Child without a costume may have sensory needs.



Model kindness.

You might be the only adult advocating for the big kids - but other adults have maybe just not thought of it… and they’re kind of swept up in the anti-teen sentiment that’s so common in society.


Be kind.


And remind the other adults around you to be too.


Advocate for children - all children - yours, mine, everyone's!


The adults nearby may need you to remind them to be kinder.

Childhood ends all too quickly - and some of these big kids are noticing that.

Give’em the candy - what’s it going to hurt?


Critics and Judgement


So about these other adults in our world. Some of them may be critical of you and your choices. Maybe it’s about the candy, the costumes, the big kids...oh, people have all sorts of reasons to criticize us, right?


Sometimes we need to stop and evaluate how much influence we want other people have on what we're deciding to do as parents. I saw a meme the other day that said, if you don’t like someone else’s parenting, why would we listen to their criticism?

That’s something to remember - whether it has to do with halloween or not, right?


Sometimes we've even internalized some of these judgements and we're our own worst critic!

As we move through this parenting phase of our lives, we often bring a need for approval with us. An unschooling approach would be to prioritize the relationship you have with your own children over the connection you have with other parents. 


You don't need their approval. Odds are, SOMEONE is going to dislike SOMETHING you do - no matter what you choose. So continue to move in the direction of strengthening those bonds with your kids!

Need Help with the Critics in Your Life?

This Unschooling Guide will give you the practical tips you need to deal with the friends, family, spouse, and even strangers who disagree with the choices you're making.


Grab this guide so you can feel more confident!

More about This Guide

Wrapping Up

About the candy...

Don’t ration it, don’t keep it from them, don’t buy it back - whatever the latest thing is.
Making it more forbidden makes it more important. The more you restrict it, the more they’ll focus on it.


About those critics, take a deep breath and make the choices YOU want to make.


About the children...prioritize advocating for the kids - big kids, little kids, your kids, my kids, everyone's kids!
Be the grown up that stands up for them. 


80+ Movie Recommendations from Unschoolers

Feel free to add more in the comments!

  • Original Twilight Zone episodes
  • The Blog
  • Godzilla
  • King Kong
  • Dracula
  • Frankenstein
  • Young Frankenstein
  • The Mummy
  • Svengoolie
  • Alien
  • Nine
  • Casper
  • Van Helsing
  • The Goonies
  • Clue
  • The Lost Boys
  • Fear Street
  • The Story Teller
  • Twitches
  • Dr Who
  • It
  • Lady in White
  • The Gremlins
  • Halloweentown
  • Dark Shadows
  • The Witches


  • Werewolf By Night (Marvel)
  • The Addams Family
  • The Munsters
  • Teen Witch
  • Hubie Halloween
  • Halloween 1 and 2
  • Goosebumps
  • Ghostbusters
  • Just Add Magic
  • Practical Magic
  • Beetlejuice
  • Corpse Bride
  • Gravity Falls
  • Hotel Transylvania
  • Teen Witch
  • The Craft
  • Practical Magic
  • April Fools Day
  • Scooby Doo
  • Elvira
  • Gravity Falls
  • The Others
  • Drop Dead Fred
  • Coraline
  • The Birds
  • Shaun of the Dead
  • The Simpsons (Edgar Allen Poe)
  • Hocus Pocus 1 & 2
  • Edward Scissorhands
  • Monster Squad
  • The Haunted Mansion
  • The Ghost & Mr.Chicken -DonKnotts
  • Scary Stories to Tell in the Dark
  • Creature from the Black Lagoon
  • Nothing But Trouble (Chevy Chase)
  • The House with a Clock in the Walls
  • The Boy Who Cried Werewolf
  • Legend of Sleepy Hollow
  • Don't Look Under the Bed
  • Something Wicked This Way Comes
  • The Curse of Bridge Hollow
  • Poltergeist (new and original)
  • The Electric Grandmother
  • Watcher in the Woods
  • Interview with a Vampire
  • Pirates of the Carribean
  • Nightmare Before Christmas
  • Buffy the Vampire Slayer
  • Little Shop of Horrors
  • Witches of Eastwick
  • The Littlest Vampire



Book Recommendations

Not as many as movies, but still might help you get your wheels turning! Reading together under the covers is so fun. Especially if it's a rainy night - what other books can I add to this list?

  • Room on the Broom
  • The Little Old Lady who was Not Afraid of Anything (don't forget the hand motions!)
  • Coraline
  • The Headless Horseman
  • House of Leaves
  • A Tale Dark and Grimm series (Adam Gidwitz)
  • The Bogwater Witches
  • The Old Lady Who Swallowed a Ghost
  • The Old Lady Who Swallowed a Bat
  • Creepy Carrots
  • Dragon's Halloween
  • Bunnicula (#1-#3)
  • The Best/Worst Halloween
  • The Little Witch
  • Halloween I Spy



Fun Things to Do with the Kids!

Unschooling Mom2Mom on Pinterest!

Lots of fun ideas over here!

By Sue Patterson 13 Apr, 2024
If you're looking into unschooling, it's not unusal to wonder, "How DO unschoolers learn school subjects?" or "How will they learn what they need to be successful adults if you don't go out a buy all the curriculum in all the typical subjects." The word, "successful," is going to mean different things to different people. Maybe it's about getting into college, or finding a good career. Maybe it's more about personal happiness - and the ability to fund that themselves. Last week, I hosted a free webinar for about a hundred people wondering this same thing. It's up at the Unschooling Mom2Mom YouTube channel now - please subscribe! We talked about the actual subjects that weave into a variety of everyday activities for kids. I have visuals and handouts - all the things to help you get more comfortable with this concept when you hop over to the description at the YouTube channel. (If you registered for the webinar, check you email inbox for the links.)
By Sue Patterson 02 Apr, 2024
Sue Patterson shares what's wrong with hanging onto a little curriculum - when you'd like to full benefit of unschooling!
By Sue Patterson 19 Mar, 2024
How do Unschooling Parents find each other? Sue Patterson shares 4 ways that work!
By Sue Patterson 09 Mar, 2024
Let's talk about "Screen Time." We need to shift our conversation with the kids about their love for technology and electronics.
How much is too much technology?
By Sue Patterson 04 Mar, 2024
How much IS too much - when it comes to gaming and surfing the web? Especially if you're going to unschool! Sue Patterson shares strategies for how to tackle the technology in your home!
By Sue Patterson 14 Feb, 2024
What's the big takeaway when an unschooling mom looks back? Lean into the Love. Originally written in 2012, and now updated for 2024, Sue Patterson share's what she wish she had known... way back when.
5 Signs it's time to Unschool
By Sue Patterson 08 Feb, 2024
5 Signs that it may be time for you to start unschooling! Whether you've been homeschooling and it's not working out as planned, or you're looking for alternatives to public schools, here are 5 Signs it may be time to start homeschooling from an unschooling perspective.
By Sue Patterson 23 Jan, 2024
Social media is in a flurry about the Pythagorean Theorem... why we learn it, how we learn it, what's the point? So I decided to ask my Robot Friend how DO we use the Pythagorean Theorem in real life. I think you'll be surprised!
By Sue Patterson 21 Jan, 2024
While no unschooling family would be considered "typical," a few characteristics are common for those who successfully unschool. Sue Patterson solves the mystery and shares what a few of these traits are. Perfect for those who are trying to figure out how to unschool or are looking for how to create a homeschooling routine.
Create a Reverse Bucket List - brainstorming on paper with Post-its
By Guest Blogger 04 Jan, 2024
Spend a little time with family creating your own "reverse bucket list" - identifying and celebrating accomplishments from this past year!
More Posts
Share by: